Table of Contents
A structural analysis tool is used to design the structure around the world.
To makes sure the structure is safe for use under the estimated loads it is expected to resist.
There are two tools generally used for structural analysis. STAAD Pro Vs ETABS is a different tool for designing 3D structures.
1. STAAD Pro
STAAD.Pro was the foremost structural analysis software to employ Matrix Methods. The matrix displacement process is employed in STAAD.
Pro to achieve stiffness analysis. The structure is first idealized into an assembly of discrete structural elements in the matrix analysis of structures employing the displacement method (frame members or finite elements).
Each part has an adopted form of displacement at the joints that meet force equilibrium and displacement compatibility.
Three STAADs can be customized to satisfy the needs of each company.
i. Benefits of STAAD Pro
The benefits of STAAD Pro are mentioned below:
a. Pro
The most basic STAAD option includes physical modeling and FEM analysis.
b. Pro Advanced
Enhances research by creating it faster, more advanced, and more complex.
c. Structural WorkSuite
A single, cost-effective license that includes the most popular structural applications.
STAAD.Pro protects nearly all the Country’s building codes and carries less memory space compared to Autodesk products. The interface is also user-friendly and uncomplicated to understand.
Regardless of which STAAD.Pro version one may select, they may confidently design concrete, timber, steel, aluminum, and cold-formed steel structures anywhere globally, employing over 90 comprised international design regulations.
Further one can:
a. Streamline their process by automatically altering the physical model to an analytical model.
b. Improve multi-discipline team communication with Bentley desktop, cloud, and mobile products, containing OpenBuildings Designer, AutoPIPE, Revit, and Tekla.
c. With full integration of physical members and surfaces, optimize concrete and steel BIM operations.
Use STAAD’s cloud services to handle multiple design alternatives in parallel and see the results in a clear, graphical format.
2. ETABS
ETABS is related to the Computers & Structures, Inc. company. ETABS is the most delinquent integrated structural analysis and building design software package.
For almost 45 years, the industry has set CSI Solvers to the test. The SAPFire Analysis Engine can accomplish Eigen and Ritz analysis and handle numerous 64-bit solvers for analysis optimization.
ETABS integrates modeling, analysis, design, and reporting into a single user interface. The number of model windows, model manipulation views, and data views is limitless.
A sort of U.S. and international design codes can be employed to create steel frames, concrete frames, cement plates, concrete shear walls, composite beams, composite columns, and steel joists.
For steel frames, concrete frames, cold-shaped steel, and aluminum frames, ETABS delivers a scope of Code-based designs.
For a broad range of gravitational, thermal, and lateral loads, ETABS presents static and dynamic analytics. The seismic reaction spectrum or accelerogram time history can be enclosed for the dynamic analysis.
ETABS can set any variety of a 3D frame and shear wall system. The shear wall element is explicitly developed for ETABS and is useful for modeling elevator core walls, curved walls, and discontinuous walls.
The wall element does not need a mesh definition, and the delivered output is not in stress but in wall forces and moments, unlike STAAD.Pro.
3. STAAD Pro vs ETABS
The STAAD Pro Vs ETABS is mentioned below in Table:
| S.N. | STAAD Pro | ETAB |
|---|---|---|
| 1. | STAAD Pro is general design software. | ETAB is best for reinforced concrete structures. |
| 2. | It is not best for a multi-story R.C.C. building. | It is suitable software to prepare a multi-story R.CC. building. |
| 3. | The interface is hard. | The interface is very effective. |
| 4. | STAAD Pro is prepared by Bently. | ETAB is prepared by CSI America. |
| 5. | STAAD Pro is compatible with to design of steel structures. | ETAB is not employed to design steel structures. |
| 6. | STAAD Pro provides expensive data for reinforcement detailing. | ETAB gives very cheap data for reinforcement detailing. |
| 7. | Most consultancies employed STAAD Pro to make structures such as steel frames, water tanks, power plants, trusses, towers, etc. | Most consultancies employed ETAB to design R.C.C. buildings. |
This was for the STAAD Pro Vs ETABS.
4. References1. Content Filter & Authenticity Checking Team, Dream Civil International (Our team checks every content & detail to maintain quality.) |
Read Also: Types of Stirrups
